Who Canceled the Border Patrols on October 7?
And when did "just following orders" become acceptable?
The good news is that tonight was the first class in my new series, prophetic teachings from Rav Elchonon Wasserman, and it was fire. The bad news is that I messed up and failed to record it. So Thursday at 9:05 PM Israel time will be a repeat of today’s class (apologies to the live participants). The link to register for the classes is https://us06web.zoom.us/meeting/register/sj2ws45FThCroxGDQYwB6w#/registration.
I previously shared video testimony from Sergeant Shalom Shitrit before the Knesset. Shitrit fought valiantly on October 7, but was gravely injured and lost a leg (you can read about it here). The video is now available with English subtitles on Rumble here and embedded above.
Shitrit recounted that at 5:20 AM on October 7, deputy battalion commander Nir Boinfeld (who was also seriously injured, but survived) got on the radio and relayed orders to cancel all patrols by the fence until 9 AM.
Boinfeld added: “I don’t know exactly why. I don’t ask too many questions. That’s the directive. That’s what we do.”
Shitrit and his comrades were similarly baffled by these orders, but, like Boinfeld, he was trained well. The first thing they teach children in school is that if you have to use the bathroom, you raise your hand and wait for permission, or else. If necessary, go in your pants. The first thing they teach you in the army is that you are nothing, and you do what you’re told, or else. If necessary, get blown up for nothing. It’s all for the greater good.
“And you know,” said Shitrit, “we’re simple soldiers, just combatants, not commanders or officers who can ask questions. It’s an order from the deputy battalion commander. We take the order and don’t ask questions.”
“Just following orders” is not the credo of a Jewish army, to put it mildly. So let’s stop pretending the IDF is a Jewish army already, and let’s stop pretending anything about this is a mitzvah.
Cannon fodder can’t ask questions, or there wouldn’t be cannon fodder.
What I find especially interesting is that this unfortunate soul, and so many like him, continue to dance around the stark reality that is staring them in the face. They express a vague desire to “understand what happened on October 7”, while cautioning that we shouldn’t jump to conclusions.
There is only one sensible conclusion to draw from an order to cancel border patrols precisely when truckloads of executioners rolled right in and committed a genocidal massacre, especially when there has been zero accountability nearly two years later.
The sensible conclusion is not that this was an “intelligence failure” or an attempt to make Bibi look bad. Seriously, why did anyone ever believe that nonsense?
They are relentlessly brainwashed and gaslighted, that’s why. Shitrit even doubted his own memory and logic until the recording of Boinfeld’s radio message became public, and he could no longer doubt that the order was given and it made no sense. That’s the power of the psychological warfare being waged on the public every moment of every day.
Even now, this tragic victim and so many like him hedge and refuse to “jump to conclusions”, pleading to the very people who betrayed them to find out what happened, someday.
There is a very simple question that neither Shitrit nor anyone in the media asked: Who gave the actual orders to cancel the patrols?
Boinfeld only relayed the order. He was a middle manager, a buffer, like when you’re chatting with customer service and ask for a supervisor. The supervisor is just an illusion of authority; he’s not a serious decision maker.
So whose idea was it? And who were they working for? Names, please. Not after the war is over and we’re all living happily ever after. Right now. Before another order is given or another mission is undertaken.
It’s the most obvious question in the world.
If we had a functioning media that wasn’t a propaganda wing of the regime, with government operatives in studios conducting the interviews, they would hound Boinfeld and everyone up the chain of command until they got names and answers. The question “Who gave the orders?” would be the main headline in every newspaper and the lead story on every newscast, demanding not just accountability but justice.
If we lived in a democracy, investigative journalists wouldn’t lose their jobs, their freedom, and quite possibly their lives if they pursued those responsible. If we lived in an actual Jewish state, with Torah as the law of the land, everyone responsible would be seeking a city of refuge, at the very minimum.
But we don’t have a functioning media, a democracy, or anything resembling a true Jewish state. We have an Amalekite/Erev Rav/globalist dictatorship, where people can be imprisoned indefinitely without being charged with a crime, where innocent people can have false confessions tortured out of them, where your most basic rights and freedoms can be snatched away at any time (for your own protection), where there is just enough semblance of democracy and Judaism to keep both the secular and religious masses deluded, no matter how bad it gets, no matter how clear it gets. (Don’t kid yourself; the rest of the world is the same, with only cultural differences.)
Who was responsible for canceling the border patrols precisely when they were needed most? And why didn’t anyone think to ask?
The following is not satire:
Kfir fighters were ordered to collect garbage in Khan Yunis under threat of mortar shells; IDF: "Maintaining hygiene" (see the link for a short video)
Fighters in the Kfir Brigade were ordered to collect trash from the front of the defensive position where they were stationed — in an area under threat from snipers and mortars in Khan Yunis, i24NEWS military correspondent Yinon Shalom Yatach reported for the first time today (Monday). The fighters' parents were furious: "A mortar landed there just yesterday," the IDF claimed: "Maintaining hygiene is essential."
According to the soldiers' parents, this was a "dangerous and unnecessary" operation. They claim that the soldiers even protested to their commanders and asked to cancel the mission, but to no avail.
On Saturday morning, a mortar shell was fired and landed exactly at the point where the soldiers were required to carry out the collection. The IDF said that the launch site from which the shooting was carried out was subsequently attacked, but the area is still considered exposed and dangerous, and the terrorist who carried out the shooting was not eliminated.
I love it. Meanwhile, they the IDF is fine with soldiers wearing second-hand underwear from the US Army, begging for toilet paper, and not showering for weeks on end. When will they give soldiers orders to shovel each other into ovens? [ed.]
Seriously, if they came out and said openly “We hate you and we want to get you killed on purpose”, people would still say it's a mitzvah to fight, so whatever.
Meanwhile, I got a letter in the mail today that they're jacking up arnona again every year until 2029, more than the automatic increases that we should expect every year just because.
Remind me again why people who aren’t slaves have to pay the government every year for the privilege of having a roof over their heads. Isn’t property ownership — really owning a home that people in uniforms with weapons can’t confiscate if you don’t pay them forever and ever — a basic human right? Isn’t the government supposed to work for us, to help preserve and increase our wealth, and not the reverse?
Why do you have to pay the government a huge chunk of your income, and then pay them sales tax every time you spend some of the money they already taxed? When does your money and property truly, completely belong to you? You were born into slavery, so you’re used to it, but you should really think about this sometime, instead of whatever the person on the screen is telling you to care about right now.
This is definitely not democracy or Judaism…it’s Eisav.
Here’s a Torah class about it: The Slavery of Taxation, and the Torah Way
Sharp comment from Rabbi Michoel Green:
The most bizarrely deranged people on earth is the Israeli left, on one hand protesting the IDF for war crimes in Gaza and on the other hand demonizing the haredim for the crime of not serving in the IDF.
Are these folks for real?
PS: I'm referring to the indoctrinated masses. With regards to govt., right and left are equally democidal.
IDF soldiers who have no compunctions about shooting harmless, defenseless Jewish "settlers" are never sent into death traps in Gaza. They are far too valuable to the regime.
Stop supporting your enemies.
Visit chananyaweissman.com for the mother lode of articles and books.
Visit rumble.com/c/c-782463 for my Torah classes, Amalek and Erev Rav programs, and much more.
Buy my books on Amazon here or contact me directly to purchase in Israel.
Download Sefer Kibbutz Galuyos pdf here or ePUB here, or buy on Amazon here.
Download Tovim Ha-Shenayim as a PDF for free!
weissmans@protonmail.com
No comments:
Post a Comment