We begin here:
[...] While Modern Orthodox Judaism was conceived to balance ancient traditions with today’s realities, it frequently appears to favor modern values over core Torah principles.
This imbalance becomes especially apparent in the community’s growing endorsement of women’s participation in combat roles within the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF). Such positions, once largely avoided on halachic grounds, now draw support from religious Zionist circles, raising questions about where adaptation ends and compromise begins.
This trend echoes the cautions of early 20th-century figures like Rabbi Abraham Isaac HaKohen Kook, who opposed women’s involvement in public life, including suffrage, viewing it as a potential disruption to family harmony and Jewish moral standards. In a similar vein, contemporary shifts in military service prompt concerns that broader societal forces are influencing halachic interpretations more than they should, often under the guise of “empowerment,” while potentially aligning with historical patterns of economic and social reconfiguration.
Halachic Foundations Under Strain
Traditional Torah sources establish firm guidelines on gender roles, particularly in areas of authority and conflict. For instance, the Rambam’s Mishneh Torah in Hilchot Melachim explicitly prohibits women from positions of serarah, or leadership, and extends this to warfare, supported by Talmudic discussions in Yevamot that highlight men’s natural role in conquest while exempting women to preserve modesty and domestic focus.
These principles have long provided exemptions for women in military duties, aligning with scriptural emphases like Psalms 45:14, which celebrates women’s strengths in more internal spheres. However, Modern Orthodox approaches are increasingly challenging these boundaries through adaptive rulings that prioritize inclusion, overlooking the amplified risks in combat environments. [...]
Continue reading the full article on Jewish Home News
No comments:
Post a Comment