PLEASE USE A NAME WHEN COMMENTING

19 November 2026

"I'm Yankel, I just went on a diet": The match that blew up, the spectacular comeback, and the su...

 


I am Yankela, I just went on a diet" | The matchmaking that was closed, and the halachic ruling of Maran Posk Hador, Rabbi Zilberstein Shlita, whether the matchmaker is entitled to matchmaking fees: The lesson for doctors that Maran Posk Hador, Rabbi Zilberstein Shlita, gave at the 'Ma'ayani Hayeshua' hospital, dealt with a fascinating halachic discussion, following a practical halachic question that reached the Posk Hador's desk. Below is the transcript of the question and the halachic ruling: "A case in which the father of an excellent girl and the embodiment of virtues approached a matchmaker and asked him to find an excellent man for his daughter, who would also meet her status. The matchmaker replied in a polite manner: I have an excellent man for you, excellent in Torah and fear of God, crowned with every right measure, his witnesses are genius and glory. The father was very excited to hear the boy's virtues and set up a meeting. The girl waited in anticipation of meeting the illustrious boy. The girl had heard such virtues about the boy, and was already looking forward to seeing him. So she stood outside And she expected to see him. But to her disappointment, as soon as she saw the guy, she almost fell over and fainted, what was the matter? He was a very fat man. A guy with all the virtues, but he had one thing, he was very fat, a man of flesh. So immediately the girl was very sorry that she had not inquired about the guy's broad dimensions. She had heard all sorts of good things about the guy, but she had not heard that he was very fat, she had not heard that. Out of no choice, so as not to offend the matchmaker, she sat down to talk to him for a few minutes. She sat down and talked to this guy. She did get the impression that he was a charming, smart, intelligent guy, with exceptional qualities, but as mentioned, the problem was external, it didn't belong, she couldn't make this match with him. Immediately after the meeting, she informed her father that the matchmaking was immediately dropped from the agenda, because it wasn't right for her to marry such a fat man. She would walk down the street with such a fat man, everyone would look at her, oh, look, look at such a girl with Ma'alot, she's going out with a very fat guy, a gifferlach, a real gifferlach. That's it, about a year has passed since that meeting, and one evening, the girl's father attended a wedding celebration, and suddenly a guy turns to him and asks: "Is your honor the father of so-and-so?" Are you the father of this wonderful girl?", the man replied in the affirmative. And the young man continued to inquire: "Don't you remember the young man Yankel'a who was proposed to you in a matchmaking about a year ago?", and again the father replied in the affirmative: "Yes, of course I remember". Well, the young man continued: "I am Yankel'a". The father looks at his interlocutor and notices that he is a handsome and rather thin young man. A young man with all the virtues and his body is also thin. The latter noticed his astonishment, and explained: "Look, over the past year I have significantly reduced my waistline through gastric bypass surgery and a special diet". After a few minutes of conversation, the father suggested returning the matchmaking, and indeed the two broke a plate, and the matchmaking was concluded with good luck, at a good and successful hour. And who appears now? The matchmaker. As soon as he heard the wonderful news, he came and sued both parties, saying: "My matchmaking was successful with the help of God, I proposed the matchmaking And you see, it's very successful. And so I'll ask to come for my salary, I want money for the match I proposed." The in-laws argued against him: "Your match fell through from the first moment, and what you proposed fell through and went away. It's just that now a new face has come here. Now it's a different guy. He looks cute, and looks handsome, and he's also had treatments, it's a different guy. You, the matchmaker, proposed a fat guy, and now there's a guy who is very thin and very handsome with all the virtues, you didn't propose that. So that's why you don't deserve a matchmaking fee." Now this question comes to us. Who is the judge? ** Here is the ruling and ruling of Maran Shlita: "Answer: One does not marry with outward appearance. A person who marries does not marry with outward appearance, but with an inner personality, with a soul. What he said, "You married a fat guy and this is another guy," is not true. When he was fat, we did not marry the fat guy either. When you marry a guy, you always marry the soul. One does not marry with outward appearance, but with an inner personality, with a soul. A person does not marry with appearance, he only marries with a soul. And in our question, the matchmaker who arranged the match for the girl's father was an excellent guy. And as we have seen, the girl was impressed by his personality and was impressed that he was smart, intel...


No comments:

MORE HAFGANOS on Yechezkel and Shmuel HaNavi

  DRAFT ARREST: Yeshiva Bochur Sentenced To 20 Days In Military Prison Just 10 Days Before His Wedding A yeshiva bochur from Rishon LeZion w...