THE MANHUNT OF חיי הישיבה — Great Elucidation by Rav Zamir and excellent MyrtleRising comparisons

 it’s nothing but a witch hunt

Rav Zamir Cohen Explains Once and For All: Why Don't Charedim Serve in the Army?

To see the original video, please click here:
habayitah.blogspot.com/2024/03/rabbi-zamir-cohen.html

Why don't charedim enlist in the Israeli army?

First of all, they do — so observes Rav Zamir Cohen (and all of us).

In fact, charedim can be found all over the army, the police force, and the healthcare system.

In addition to serving as doctors and nurses, charedim run and staff organizations like Yad Sara, Ezer MiTzion, Efrat, Ima ("Mother" — Hidabroot's pro-life organization), and more. 

And charedi wholly staff the paramedic organization, Hatzola, and the organization ZAKA, which saves lives as first responders, but its main job is the heart-breaking and gruesome task of collecting dead bodies, body parts, blood, and tissue for respectful burial.

(Because of the policies of the same people who wish to draft into military service every single charedi — including the devoted yeshivah men — ZAKA and Hatzola are kept quite busy cleaning up the gruesome and heart-breaking results of these policies. One can make the argument that pro-life orgs such as Efrat and Ima, plus the anti-assimilation org Yad L'Achim — which also rescues Jewish women and children trapped with Muslim-Arab husbands or partners in Muslim-Arab villages — are also cleaning up the results of secular Leftist policies.)

So the demand for charedim to serve is actually a demand for the [me: ONLY] kollel avrechim and  [me: ONLY] yeshivah bochurim to serve.

To read please more https://myrtlerising.weebly.com/blog/rav-zamir-cohen-explains-once-and-for-all-why-dont-charedim-serve-in-the-army

NOTE:  “ Rav Zamir quotes the results of a survey, in which they discovered that the group of religious Zionist Jews known as "charedi-dati-leumi" suffered the loss of 210 Jews going off the derech out of every thousand who completed army service, while the mainstream dati-leumi suffer the loss of 310 out of 1000. What's known as dati-leumi "lite" suffers the loss of 510 per 1000.”

FURTHER: “ So while heartbreaking and infuriating, the recent tragedy involving many soldiers from the Netzach Yehudah brigade in Gaza (with soldiers from mostly charedi families) isn't a shock, coming on the heels of recent reports of the Medinah's preparations to criminalize Torah learners.

But the Israeli military planned a widespread attack against Torah, using its own people to hunt down and arrest yeshivah students.

And now the Israeli military suffered a horrific loss (not to mention the terrible wounds endured by the surviving soldiers).