Reb Sones: The Moral Imperative: A Call to Action ‘When Silence Is a Sin’

 When Israel’s future is at stake, silence is not an option - it is a sin

In the wake of the Six-Day War of 1967, as Israel stood at a crossroads of triumph and tension, one voice emerged with unwavering clarity: Rabbi Menachem M. Schneerson, the Lubavitcher Rebbe. His teachings, delivered between 1970 and 1980 and later compiled into the book When Silence Is a Sin, articulate a bold and cohesive ideology that transcends its historical moment.

Far from a mere reaction to geopolitical upheaval, the Rebbe’s message is a timeless call to moral and religious action, rooted in Jewish law and an unshakable commitment to the Land of Israel’s security and sovereignty. We will explore the essence of that ideology, as presented in the book, and its enduring relevance for a world still wrestling with the same questions of duty, unity, and destiny.

At its core, the Rebbe’s ideology hinges on a single, seismic principle: silence in the face of threats to Israel’s integrity is not neutrality—it is a sin. This conviction, unpacked across the book’s three meticulously structured sections—the obligation to protest, practical directives for sovereignty, and the duty to settle the entire Land of Israel—demands active resistance to any compromise that endangers Jewish lives or the divine promise of the land. Grounded in halacha (Jewish law) and the principle of pikuach nefesh (the preservation of life), the Rebbe’s vision is both a spiritual manifesto and a pragmatic blueprint for safeguarding Israel’s future.

A Nation at a Crossroads: The Historical Context

To grasp the weight of the Rebbe’s ideology, one must first step back to the turbulent years following the Six-Day War. Israel’s lightning victory had expanded its borders, bringing eastern Jerusalem including the Temple Mount, Judea, Samaria, Gaza Strip, Golan Heights, and Sinai Peninsula under its control. Yet this triumph was shadowed by mounting international pressure to cede these territories “for peace,” and by fierce internal debates over the nation’s path forward. It was a moment of both opportunity and peril, as the Jewish state navigated its newfound strength amid threats to its survival.

Into this confusion stepped the Rebbe, not as a political figure but as a spiritual luminary. His talks, delivered at farbrengens (Chassidic gatherings) and later published in 2005 by Sichos In English as When Silence Is a Sin, reflect a profound concern for the safety of the Jewish people and the sanctity of their homeland. The book’s structure—divided into three sections—mirrors the Rebbe’s holistic approach: a call to protest rooted in moral duty, actionable steps to assert sovereignty, and a vision of settlement as a religious imperative. Together, these elements form a unified ideology that fuses morality with urgency.

The Obligation to Protest: A Halachic Imperative

The first pillar of the Rebbe’s ideology is a clarion call for Jewish leaders, particularly rabbis, to publicly oppose any concessions of land. This is no mere suggestion—it is a halachic obligation, grounded in the Shulchan Aruch (Laws of Shabbos, ch. 329), which forbids actions that endanger Jewish lives. For the Rebbe, ceding territory is not a diplomatic choice but a direct violation of pikuach nefesh, as it invites aggression and jeopardizes the nation’s security.

In a talk from Yud Shvat, 5730 (1970), the Rebbe minced no words: “The murder of Jews in Israel, may G‑d save us, and the maiming of scores of Jews, may they have a complete and speedy recovery, is a direct result of the surrender of land to the gentiles.” This stark assessment frames silence as complicity, a betrayal of both faith and people. To drive this home, the Rebbe took action, inviting rabbis to farbrengens and pressing them to issue public rulings against land concessions. When over 100 rabbis signed a resolution—surpassing his symbolic target of 72—it underscored the resonance of his message.

The Rebbe’s vision of protest extended beyond Israel’s borders, rejecting the idea that diaspora rabbis should remain silent. He invoked the principle of Jewish unity from the Tanya, Iggeres HaKodesh, Epistle 31, which describes all Jewish souls as interconnected, each one’s actions impacting the collective spiritual structure of the nation. Drawing on the Talmudic concept from Shevuot 39a, “All of Israel are guarantors for one another,” he emphasized that every Jew shares responsibility for the community’s welfare, making it a halachic duty to speak out against threats to the Land of Israel’s security. “Every rabbi’s ruling affects the reality of the world,” he declared, likening modern rabbis to the prophets Shmuel and Moshe—figures whose words shaped history. For the Rebbe, protest is a sacred act, a means of aligning the Jewish people with their divine mission.

Practical Directives for Sovereignty: From Words to Action

If the obligation to protest lays the moral foundation, the second section of When Silence Is a Sin builds a bridge to action. Here, the Rebbe shifts from rhetoric to pragmatism, offering concrete steps to strengthen Israel’s sovereignty. “The main thing is action,” he insisted in a talk from the 28th of Nissan, 5737 (1977), urging rabbis to issue unambiguous halachic rulings and publicize them widely. This, he argued, flows directly from the biblical command, “Do not stand idly by your brother’s blood”—a mandate that applies to the entire Jewish nation.

The Rebbe also tackled practical concerns head-on. He called for security decisions to be informed by military experts rather than politicians, drawing a vivid analogy: “If a person requires surgery, G‑d forbid, does he consult a politician or a doctor?” This insistence on expertise over expediency reflects his belief that protecting Jewish lives demands clarity and competence, not compromise. His letters to government officials, referenced in the book, further illustrate this hands-on approach, as he pressed for policies that prioritized safety over diplomacy.

Critics might argue that rabbis lack the authority to weigh in on such matters, but the Rebbe was unmoved. This is not about politics, he countered—it is about halacha. When lives hang in the balance, silence violates Jewish law, and action becomes non-negotiable. His ideology thus fuses moral urgency with practical resolve, demanding a united front to safeguard Israel’s future.

Settling the Entire Land: A Divine Mandate

The third pillar of the Rebbe’s ideology elevates the discussion to a cosmic plane: the religious duty to settle the entire Land of Israel. This is not merely a strategic goal but a fulfillment of Jewish destiny, rooted in Torah and Talmudic sources. In a talk from the 19th of Kislev, 5738 (1977), the Rebbe asserted that the land is a divine inheritance, and abandoning any part of it undermines the spiritual and physical wholeness of the nation. He tied this to the concept of Shleimus HaAretz (the completeness of the land), which, alongside Shleimus HaTorah (the completeness of the Torah) and Shleimus HaAm (the completeness of the people), forms the bedrock of Jewish sovereignty.

Settlement, in the Rebbe’s view, is a redemptive act. By inhabiting the land and living according to Torah values, Jews not only secure their physical presence but also hasten the Messianic era. “The land belongs to the Jewish people by divine right,” he proclaimed, framing this duty as both a privilege and a commandment. His vision is expansive: a united Jewish people, rooted in their homeland, serving as a “light unto the nations” and drawing the world closer to its ultimate purpose.

Refuting the Doubters: The Power of Conviction

The Rebbe’s ideology is not without its challengers, and When Silence Is a Sin anticipates their objections with piercing clarity. To those who claim protest is futile, he cites Maimonides (Mishneh Torah, Laws of Repentance, 3:4): “One act can swing the balance of the entire world.” The outcome may be uncertain, but the obligation remains absolute. To those who question rabbinic qualifications, he reiterates that this is a matter of halacha, not strategy—when danger looms, Jewish law demands a response.

Perhaps the most human objection is the fear of being ignored or mocked. Here, the Rebbe’s response is both profound and personal: protest stems from pain, from love for one’s fellow Jews, and from a refusal to stand by in the face of peril. Even if it fails to sway policy immediately, it fulfills a sacred duty and sows seeds for change. This blend of pragmatism and passion underscores the depth of his ideology, making it as much a call to the heart as to the mind.

A Living Legacy: Relevance in Today’s World

More than four decades after these talks were delivered, the Rebbe’s ideology retains its urgency. Israel still faces threats to its security and sovereignty, from border disputes to international pressure for concessions. The questions he posed—What is the role of Jewish leaders in crisis? How do we weigh pragmatism against principle?—echo in today’s headlines. In this light, When Silence Is a Sin is not a relic but a guide, challenging us to confront these dilemmas with courage and conviction.

The Rebbe’s message is clear: when Israel’s future is at stake, silence is not an option. His ideology—woven from halacha and history—offers a roadmap for action, urging Jews to unite in defense of their land and their destiny. As he declared, “The main thing is action,” and that action begins with breaking the silence. In a world where the stakes remain high, the Rebbe’s voice continues to resonate, a beacon for those willing to heed its call.

https://jewishhome.news/